Fundamentals of Fluid Mechanics Questions and Answers  
Question by AME536A Student
CV.JPG  ./download/file.php?id=7193  ./download/file.php?id=7193&t=1
I meant to say that the density for the control volume was assumed to be uniform at every time interval. Is this assumption incorrect and if so, why? In the example problem showed in class you made this assumption as well so if we cannot make it when are we allowed to make it?
11.07.20
This is a good question but you need to provide more information. Which question of which assignment is this? Part a or b? Also, you need to show the drawing of your control volume that you provided in your assignment.
Question by AME536A Student
cv1.JPG
I apologize, that is for both part A and part B of Question 3 of Assignment 6. For part A my control volume is the portion of the tank that only contains the air; for part B it is the entirety of the tank as all water has been drained.
The problem is this: your control volume encloses all the volume inside the tank. Thus, inside the control volume, there is both air and water. In your solution you mention that the integral $\int_V \rho dV$ becomes $\rho_{\rm A} V_{\rm A}$. This is not correct here because the density in the volume is not constant and equal to $\rho_{\rm A}$ but varies because there is also water within the volume with a density $\rho_{\rm W}$.
Question by AME536A Student
cv2.JPG
Understood. If I redraw my control volume to be only around the air portion of the tank and only at the instant of (to be the blue line for Part A and the Red dashed line for Part B), would this resolve the logical issue?
Then, in this case, you can assume constant density within the blue volume at one given time. But, this won't fix all the problems because now you have a moving boundary on the bottom of the blue domain. So you need to use a different form that is applicable to a moving surface (with $\vec{v}_{\rm CV}$ taken into account). If you can't find this form in the tables, you need to derive it using the Reynolds transport theorem.
11.08.20
Question by AME536A Student
There will be a moving boundary, but we do not need to consider it to solve the problem. In part A, the boundary of the system will not move until after the pressure has reached 5 bar and the temperature of the system has reached the temperature of interest. For part B, the final pressure and volume are given in the problem statement so we have a fixed state (only 2 independent intensive properties needed to fix a state). The amount of time it takes for the water to drain will not affect the final temperature as the conditions of the system are not dependent on the rate at which it gets there.
You are missing the point. You are using (and have to use) the CV form of the equations to solve the problem, not another approach. If you locate the CV around the air for part (b) as you did, you must introduce the velocity of the moving surface within your solution, by deriving an energy equation in integral form using the Reynolds transport theorem and the energy equation in differential form. The velocity of the moving surface should cancel out in the end as you point out, but this needs to be proven within the context of the control volume equations applicable to a domain with a moving boundary. Otherwise, your logic is incorrect even if you arrive at the right answer.
Question by AME536A Student
I have a question about Prob #1 in the assignment 7. In order to find the wind speed of the flow going toward the prototype windmill, I have used another nondimensional number other than Re and $C_{D}$. The common parameters used to make the new nondimensional number are $\rho$, D, W(angular velocity of blade). A extra parameter used is $q_{\infty}$. As a result, I got another nondimensional number $q_{\infty}$/ W. My logic used to get the wind speed is $q_{\infty proto}$/ $W_{proto}$ = $q_{\infty model}$/$W_{model}$ and I got the $q_{\infty proto}$, but the answer is incorrect. I was wondering if I choose wrong common parameters and extra parameter.
11.09.20
This sounds more or less correct. But what units does the angular velocity of the blade have? Radians per second?
Previous   1  ...  16 ,  17 ,  18  ...  39    Next  •  PDF 1✕1 2✕1 2✕2
$\pi$